FULL COMMISSION MEETING

Clayton E. Hutcheson Agricultural Center Exhibit Halls A & B

559 N. Military Trail, West Palm Beach, FL 33415

 

Monday, August 24, 2026 at 12:00 PM

 

MEETING MINUTES

[25] MEMBERS PRESENT

 

 

 

Members Present:

Alexcia Cox, State Attorney, 15th Judicial Circuit

Cesar Daniel Arbolaez, Pastor, Passion Church

Chief Sean Bramer, FAU PD

Cyrus Toufanian, The Toufanian Law Firm, P.A./CJC Member

Daniel Eisinger, Public Defender, 15th Judicial Circuit

Darcy Davis, Chief Executive Officer, HealthCare District

Demetrios Thomas, Special Agent Supervisor at Florida Department of Law Enforcement

Dr. Deeawn Roundtree, CEO of Roundtree Training and Consulting

Erica Whitfield, PBC School District 4

Gina Fraga, Economic Council/CJC Member

Glenn Kelley, Chief Judge, 15th Judicial Circuit

Gregory Starling, Chief Probation Officer, Circuit 15, Florida Department of Juvenile Justice

Heather Destefano, Palm Health Foundation

Jervonte Edmonds, Florida State Representative, District 88 and PBC Legislative Delegate

Joel G. Flores, Palm Beach County Commissioner, District 3

Jorge Garrido, CJC Treasurer

Julia Dattolo, President/CEO, CareerSource PBC

Kathleen Kroll, Administrative Judge, Juvenile Division

Lawrence Gordon, Vice Mayor, Town of Haverhill & PBC League of Cities

Maria S. Antuña, CJC Vice Chair

Michael Coleman, President, Palm Beach County Association of Chiefs of Police

Michelle Suskauer, CJC Chair

Nellie L. King, Attorney, the Law Offices of Nellie L. King, P.A.

Oswald Newbold, Reentry Coordinator, the Reentry Center of Riviera Beach

Sherri Resnick, Economic Council/CJC Member

Talal Masri for Ric Bradshaw, Palm Beach County Sheriff, PBSO

Vanessa Klein, Director of Reentry Services, The Lord's Place

 

Members Absent:

Adam McMichael, Assistant United States Attorney, Southern District of Florida

Antonio Araujo, Chief, West Palm Beach Police Department

Derek Gibson, Circuit Administrator, Florida Department of Corrections

Gerald Richman, Gerald F. Richman, PLLC/CJC Member

Jerry C. Leakey, The Legal Aid Society/CJC Member

Karen Hansen, CJC Secretary

Shannon Ramsey-Chessman, Interim Clerk of Court, PBC Clerk and Comptroller

Sheri Resnick, Founder and President of Working Gears, LLC.

 

 

 

Guests Present:

Angelique J. Pickett, PSAIC

Barbara Gerlock, C15 JJAB/PBCCAC

Chief Randall Anderson, PBG PD

Chief Stephen Stepp, PBG PD Interim Chief

David Kahn, HR Director

Jessica Hidalgo, Reentry Services, Palm Beach County Public Safety Department

Joanne Keller, PBC

Kiava Kelly, Legislature

Liz Herman, PBC

Raima Sarker, Legislation

Zach Ives, PBC Clerk and Comptroller

Jean Williams, Assistant County Attorney, Palm Beach County

 

Virtual Guests Present:

Arlene Griffiths, Reentry Services, PBC PSD

Derek Gibson, Florida Department of Corrections

Shirlon St. Amour, Reentry Services, PBC PSD

Stephanie Sejnoha, Director, Public Safety Department

 

CJC Staff Present:

Akil Taylor, Data Analyst

Jennifer Sellars, Research and Planning Manager

Katherine Hatos, Criminal Justice Systems Manager

Margo Smith, Administrative Assistant III

Taruna Malhotra Executive Director

 

I.            Call to Order

  • Chair, Michelle Suskauer called the meeting to order.

 

II.            Roll Call

·         Katherine Hatos, Criminal Justice Systems Manager, completed roll call of the members and determined there was quorum.

 

III.            ​Approval and/or corrections to the Agenda

·         The agenda was approved with one correction to remove the legislative update as the Legislative Affairs Director, Alessandro Marchesani, was not present.

·         Commissioner Flores made a motion to approve the agenda, seconded by Jorge Garrido and passed unanimously.

·         Nellie King inquired about when the agenda was posted and about the meeting being publicly noticed as it appeared to be listed in two different locations.  She stated that the public notice may have caused confusion among the members as it had the old location posted as well as the new location.  Nellie King also questioned the public notice for the zoom link for the meeting as well.

·         Chair Michelle Suskauer assured the members that notifications were sent out this morning reminding members of the new location.  She was not aware the meetings were posted on the CJC website but did confirm that several notifications were sent out regarding the new location.

·         Executive Director Taruna Malhotra stated that she would check and make sure going forward that the public notices are correct.  She mentioned that she sent notification to our Office of Technology and Innovation as well.  She also announced that an online link was provided so the public could attend virtually, which is a first. Chair Suskauer confirmed that this is a great opportunity to allow more engagement from the public. She also assured Nellie that if that was the case, they would ensure it doesn't happen again.

 

IV.            Approval and/or Corrections to the May 18, 2026 Meeting Minutes

·         Representative Jervonte Edmonds made a motion to approve the minutes, seconded by Jorge Garrido and passed unanimously.

 

V.            Chair Comments

A.     Chair Suskauer congratulated Erica Whitfield on becoming a new County Commissioner.

B.     Chair Suskauer welcomed the New CJC Members that include Dr. Deeawn Roundtree, Cyrus Toufanian, and Jerry C. Leakey

C.  Welcome new CJC Member Chief Sean Brammer, FAU PD.

D.   Welcome new CJC Member, Adam McMichael, AUSA.

o   Nellie King raised the question of whether this federal seat was eliminated years ago; Chair Suskauer confirmed that according to current documents this seat is still present. There may have been discussion, but the seat has not been eliminated, and we welcome Adam McMichael to the CJC.

E Nominating Committee recommendation for the CJC student seat: Mark Dorestin is scheduled for the BOCC approval on October 20, 2026.

F. CJC Annual Report BCC Presentation scheduled for September 1, 2026; presentation is attached to the packet for your review.

G. Establishing the CJC as the independent Office of the Criminal Justice Commission is scheduled for September 1, 2026.

 

VI.            Executive Director Updates

A.     A BOCC workshop on the vaping epidemic was held in June and the Board directed CJC staff to explore an ordinance restricting new vaping stores within 1000 feet of schools.  However, SB 180 imposes a freeze on such action until October 2027; after this time period we will bring a draft ordinance back to the CJC Board for your comments and review. Thank you to Chief Coleman and Representative Jervonte Edmonds for joining us during the BOCC workshop.

B.     The CJC Strategic Plan is in development, with a community survey to be sent out shortly and community conversations planned. We are working with our Strategic Planner and Sheri Resnick to continue development. We are also working with our community partners as we develop community conversations to include the wider public.

C.      CJC staff were selected to participate in an initiative on Prison Education Program Data Analytics Cohort; local research is planned for Palm Beach County to make sure we are connecting folks coming out of prison to the right programs and employment. We are working with PBC staff to determine how we might utilize the same analytics with our local PBC data.  

D.     The CJC submitted an application on August 17th to participate in the Actionable Intelligence for Social Policy (AISP) Learning Community, which would provide technical assistance and peer learning opportunities focused on responsible data integration across criminal justice, health and human services, and community systems. On September 14 there is a data sharing agreement going before the County Commissioners. This was one of the asks from the CJC and PSCC to have data sharing between the homeless system, behavioral health, and criminal justice jail data. Once approved we will start working with our partners on data integration.

E.     The CJC submitted an NIJ research grant application for a four-year $750,000 Human Trafficking Grant in partnership with FAU, and with support from the Palm Beach Sheriff's Office, to do the research and evaluation on human trafficking. This was an ask from Mayor Baxter and Commissioner Flores during a previous BOCC meeting. This opportunity will also allow for interns to work on this project. We will hopefully know by next month if we are selected for this funding opportunity.

 

F.      The CJC received the 2026 NACo Achievement Award for the 10-week Justice Leadership Academy.

 

CJC staff are working with the Clerk's office and our Office of Technology and Innovation (OTI) on the technical specifications and will be able to add the real time crime data and trends and use this data for future research purposes. Thank you to the Sheriff's office for helping us to obtain the jail data. The jail population data dashboards are being developed in partnership with the clerk's office and Sheriff's office showing the daily population, average trends, felony and misdemeanor charges, and population characteristics. We have been working with the Public Defender's office, Jennifer Loyless, and the Palm Beach County Justice Services team to refine the data and what is pertinent to our stakeholders so we can be more data driven; we are also planning to work with the Health Care District to ensure a comprehensive look at people coming out of our justice system. A public facing site is planned to be implemented within a few months.  

 

Question: Commissioner Flores asked about the daily jail population count date. This example is for August 6; it looks like this number is higher than a year ago. Without regularly looking at the data, it appears this number is higher than normal. But I don't see that crime rates are higher. Why do we have more people in jail? Length of stay? Part of our mission is to manage the population and make sure we are being efficient and effective. Can we look at this for the next meeting?

 

Answer: Executive Director Malhotra responded, yes, there will be another summary detail tab where we will be showing the average length of stay which will help us better understand the current state; this data will also help us to identify any bottlenecks or system inefficiencies.

 

The members discussed exploring several possible contributing factors to the increasing jail population numbers, including officers choosing to physically book individuals rather than issue notices to appear, possibly facilitating immigration status checks. It was noted by Colonel Masri that immigration detainees are typically processed and picked up by ICE within 24-48 hours. Immigration arrests are usually based on state charges. Member question: Does the jail have a contract with ICE? Answer: No, ICE will send their own people to pick up within 48 hours. The State of Florida does have a contract with ICE; those individuals may be included in this higher population number. Public Defender, Daniel Eisinger, noted that the number of people going to court, those numbers are down; it was suggested that instead of a notice being given to appear, people are taken to jail to determine if they are in the country lawfully; according to the Public Defender, the out of custody numbers are down. This could be impacting the higher jail population numbers.

 

The statewide changes to scheduled bond by the legislature and Supreme Court could be another contributing factor across Florida, as there are similar trends in Miami-Dade and Broward counties. The Public Defender noted that due to these policies and legislative changes the jail populations are increasing across the state; there are multiple factors contributing to the increased numbers. Mental health cases that are captured in the data as extremely long lengths of stay, are broken down into different facilities, including the State Hospitals.

 

Question: Are we able to separate out the people that are pretrial in custody, and serving their sentence?

Answer: Yes, once we have the Clerk's data, we will be able to see this information.

Question: Can we identify an immigration hold with this data?

Answer: I believe so, and we will check.

Question: Commissioner Flores asked for a further explanation about the prison education program cohort mentioned under Director updates. Director Malhotra shared that this is  an analytical tool in which CJC staff are trained to look at jail data for those incarcerated and their education level. Also, what new education skills they are jailing and how we are using that information so when they are released to connect them with the right opportunities. It was mentioned that the jail mostly provides GED. Commissioner Flores also noted the tablet program previously mentioned by the Public Defender's office.

Answer: Public Defender Eisinger reported that the Sheriff is meeting with vendors to bring tablets into the jail to increase access to educational programs, their cases, and email. Department of Corrections has had these tablets for a long time, and other counties do utilize them. Discussions are underway regarding this, and the costs associated with it. Currently only GED and drug treatment in Belle Glade are being offered. The Sheriff's office supports this.

Chair Suskauer requested that this be brought back to the next meeting to discuss and that the CJC provide a letter of support for this initiative.

 

CJC Staff are committed to presenting a live dashboard with more detailed data at the next meeting; a jail assessment trend team has been working on these data points and will share their work at the next PSCC meeting. Once there is access to the Clerk's data there will be more information for a deeper dive. 

 

These dashboards will provide a platform for the CJC Board to explore these issues further; this is what is needed.

 

Summary of Questions, Answers & Comments

Q: A question was raised about inmates with extremely long incarceration records, with staff indicating the longest cases appeared to be mental health-related individuals who had spent time in the state hospital. 

A: Staff also confirmed they are working on obtaining clerk's data to distinguish pretrial detainees from those serving sentences. 

 

VII.            Presentations

A.    Law Enforcement Highlights

·         Chief Sean Brammer of the FAU Police Department presented on the department's Drone First Responders Program, which can deploy drones to any area of campus within 60 seconds in response to threats, protests, or incidents. FAU was noted as the first college or university in Florida to implement this program. The department oversees six campuses across three counties with about 34,000 students. We have 6,000 students living on campus, and just opened a 670 bed facility; University President is aiming to have 10,000 students on campus by 2032, across multiple campuses. The department is staffed at approximately 75 out of 83 authorized officers.

·         Q: Have you seen a decrease in opioid incidents?

·         A: We have not had opioid issues on our campuses.

 

 

B.    Legislative Updates

·         Representative Jervonte Edmonds provided a legislative update including the impact of the property taxes proposal on the upcoming election. It requires 60% of the State of Florida to pass this ballot initiative. And if it does pass, it will start January 1, 2027. If passed homestead exemptions will increase from $50,000 to $150,000 in the first year, and to $250,000 in the second year; the year after is based on inflation. In order to qualify for the exemption, owners must own their homes for at least 5 years. In 2030 municipalities and counties will have the ability to remove this criteria. Non homesteaded properties will move to 5% from 10%, further reducing ad valorum funds.

·         Looking ahead, there will likely be bills to remove business tax which will leave counties with further reduced funds. Legislation on data centers, SB 496, will likely return this session.

·         He also discussed criminal justice priorities in Tallahassee that typically address domestic violence, animal cruelty, and child sexual offenses. Additional updates included:

o   Amendments 1 (increasing reserves) and 2 (tax credit for farming usage property), covering state reserves and farm property tax relief respectively

o   Hometown Heroes ($50 million) and My Safe Florida programs/ SHIP and SAIL programs/ LIHEAP

o   Restored Tri Rail funding restored approximately $40 million 

o   Nearly $60 million awarded for water restoration and $10 million for Lake Worth Lagoon and surrounding areas

 

VIII.            Old Business

A.    E-Bike Ordinance update

  • An E-Bike Ordinance is on the BOCC agenda for approval on October 6, 2026.  The key provisions include a minimum age of 15, requirement for government issued ID, a maximum speed of 15 mph on sidewalks, and 10 mph within 15 feet of a pedestrian.   The ordinance covers electric bicycles, motorized scooters, and other qualifying micromobility devices. Applicable where Palm Beach County has traffic control jurisdiction. Helmets are only required for riders under 15, as preemption prevents requiring helmets for adults. There will also be an education campaign working with the schools and community partners to address safety issues and best practices.

 

IX.            New Business

A.     CJC Ordinance Recommendations from the Nominating Committee Discussion

  • The CJC Nominating Committee requested the addition of a second youth CJC seat which was prompted by strong applications including one application from a high school student. 
  • There was an ask of the Nominating Committee to also change the term to two years. However, there is a PBC Resolution that requires a 3-year term, so we won't be able to change the term. But if the board desires to add another youth seat, then I can work on amending the ordinance.
    • Question: Is this a voting seat?
    • Answer: Yes, it is a voting seat. This can also be decided by the Board and amending the ordinance.
  • The members discussed amending the Bylaws to add a youth seat with BOCC approval in November or December.  The age was confirmed as 17-22 years of age.

Chief Coleman made a motion to approve, seconded by Maria Antuna, and one opposed.


​X.            Discussion Items/Updates

A.    Research Projects

  1. Executive Director Malhotra discussed the current research projects the CJC is working on that include Palm Beach County High Utilizer Systems Analysis to identify individuals frequently involved in multiple systems, and a review of existing county jail programs to identify service gaps and best practices.
  1. The second research project is the Juvenile Jail Education and Reentry Services Evaluation. Best practice models will be brought back to the CJC Board.

 

XI.            Task Force Reports

  1. Executive Director Malhotra discussed the BHSUCOD Master Plan and BHTF Mapping to align tasks. The Behavioral Health Task Force reported aligning its priorities with the county Behavioral Health Master Plan and Juvenile Advisory Board to reduce siloed work and improve coordination. We are working directly with those boards to transition tasks to the appropriate board, reducing duplication. We will not lose information, as all information will be brought back to the CJC Board.
     

    The task force report updates are included in the meeting packet. Members are encouraged to look at the work of each task force and let the Chair know if you want to be a member of a particular task force because it resonates with you or you have a skill set that you think might be helpful.
     

    Member Comments
  • New member Dr. Deeawn Roundtree expressed her concern with not being able to get in contact with anyone as she was not able to find the meeting location.  She explained that she sent several emails and texts with no response.  She went to the CJC office at government center where she previously completed her new member onboarding.  However, she could not find out any information about the meeting.  She finally found her way to the meeting but was disappointed that there was confusion.  CJC staff provided her with their contact information and assured her that the confusion should not be an issue moving forward. 

    Regarding school zone cameras, during school hours, there have been complaints. Are they constitutional? There needs to be information pushed out on this issue.

    Chair Suskauer advised that they checked regarding Nellie King's comment about the US Attorney seat. There was nothing that was amended deleting that seat.

     

    Guest Comments

    Public commented that the motion made to add an additional student seat violated the CJC Bylaws as it is the Ordinance.

    County Attorney Jean Williams confirmed that the motion to add another student seat was within the CJC Ordinance guidelines.

    Adjournment – Meeting Adjourned

     

 

Next Meeting: Monday, September 28, 2026 at 12:00 PM

Clayton E. Hutcheson Agricultural Center Exhibit Halls A & B

559 N. Military Trail, West Palm Beach, FL 33415